Javeria Saud Fires Back: “The Mindset is Dirty, Not Karachi”

Actress Javeria Saud has issued a sharp rebuttal to fellow actresses Saba Qamar and Iffat Omar for their critical comments about Karachi, stating that the city is not “dirty,” but rather, the mindset of those labeling it as such is.

The controversy began when Saba Qamar, in a podcast, expressed her dislike for Karachi and said she would never move there, a sentiment she emphasized by saying “Astaghfirullah.” The following day, actress Iffat Omar defended Qamar’s right to an opinion but doubled down on the criticism by explicitly calling Karachi a “dirty city.”

Actress Ainy Jaffri Reveals Childhood Harassment Incident by Domestic Worker

Javeria Saud, who hails from Karachi, responded by sharing screenshots of the news about both actresses on her Instagram Story. Without naming them directly, she wrote a powerful retort: “Karachi is not ‘dirty,’ the people who call it ‘dirty’ have a dirty mindset.”

She expanded on this, stating that some people are themselves “dirtying” their own country. Her core argument was that “cities are not dirty, rather, people’s thinking is dirty.” In a message of unity, she concluded by expressing her love for every part of Pakistan, whether it’s Karachi or any other city.

FAQs: Javeria Saud’s Defense of Karachi

1. What did Javeria Saud say exactly?
She stated, “Karachi is not ‘dirty,’ the people who call it ‘dirty’ have a dirty mindset.” She argued that the problem lies with people’s negative perceptions, not the city itself.

2. Who was she responding to?
Her comments were a direct response to actresses Saba Qamar and Iffat Omar, who had recently made negative remarks about living in and the condition of Karachi.

3. What is the main point of her argument?
Her main point is that blaming the city is counterproductive. The real issue is a negative and critical mindset, and she believes citizens should show love for all parts of their country instead of publicly disparaging them.

4. Is this just about cleanliness?
While the word “dirty” (ganda) can refer to physical cleanliness, in this context, it’s a broader critique. Javeria is responding to the overall negative characterization of the city and its dismissal as an undesirable place to live.

5. Why is this a significant topic in Pakistan?
Karachi is Pakistan’s largest city and economic hub. It faces real challenges with infrastructure and waste management, but it is also home to millions who are deeply proud of it. Public criticism from celebrities often sparks intense debate about civic pride, responsibility, and the portrayal of major cities.