Fawad Khan’s Role on Pakistan Idol Judge Panel Sparks Industry Debate

A recent criticism of actor and singer Fawad Khan’s inclusion in the Pakistan Idol judge panel has triggered a strong wave of support from his peers in the entertainment industry, turning a single comment into a major talking point.

The controversy began when singer Hamiera Arshad, during a TV appearance, objected to Fawad Khan being a judge on the popular music reality show. She argued that judge panels should consist exclusively of individuals who have dedicated their entire lives to music, implying that actors or other artists need not apply.

Fawad Khan’s Bollywood Film ‘Abir Gulaal’ Banned in India

However, Hamiera’s comments were met with swift backlash from several prominent showbiz personalities, who rushed to defend Fawad Khan’s credentials.

Actress Ayesha Omar took to Instagram to outline Fawad’s extensive musical background. She reminded everyone that Fawad was the lead vocalist for the iconic Pakistani rock band Entity Paradigm (EP), which won the first season of Battle of the Bands. She also pointed out that he has prior experience as a judge on Pepsi Battle of the Bands for three seasons, where his feedback was known for being deep and constructive.

Actor Haroon Shahid called the debate “extremely foolish” on X (formerly Twitter), expressing concern that Hamiera seemed unaware of Fawad Khan and fellow judge Bilal Maqsood’s stature as musicians.

Other actors, including Nomi Khan and Dur-e-Fishan Saleem, also voiced their support. Nomi Khan shared a video of Fawad’s career highlights, criticizing the tendency to pull down successful people. Dur-e-Fishan called out the “shameful” habit of publicly undermining peers while smiling at them in person, advocating for healthier, more professional criticism instead.

The incident has sparked a broader conversation about artistic credentials and the nature of criticism within the Pakistani entertainment industry.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

1. What was Hamiera Arshad’s criticism?
She stated that only people who have devoted their entire lives to music should be judges on shows like Pakistan Idol, and expressed disapproval of artists from other fields taking such roles.

2. What is Fawad Khan’s musical background?
Fawad Khan was the lead singer of the famous rock band Entity Paradigm (EP). He rose to fame after his band won the first Battle of the Bands competition. He has also been a judge on Pepsi Battle of the Bands.

3. How did other celebrities react?
Many came to Fawad’s defense, including Ayesha Omar, Haroon Shahid, Nomi Khan, and Dur-e-Fishan Saleem. They highlighted his proven musical career and criticized what they saw as unnecessary negativity.

4. Has Fawad Khan been a judge before?
Yes, he served as a judge for three seasons on the music competition show Pepsi Battle of the Bands before joining Pakistan Idol.

5. What is the core of this debate?
The debate centers on what qualifies someone to be a music judge whether it requires a lifetime dedicated solely to music or if a successful and experienced artist with a diverse career, like Fawad Khan, is equally qualified. It also touches on the culture of public criticism among Pakistani artists.